2012 — Tyre Coleman, DE, East Region Defensive Player of the Year
2014 — Tyre Coleman, DE, East Region Defensive Player of the Year
 

2005—Doug Blakowski, RB, second team
2005—Tony Clemente, LB, second team
2005—Rick Eicheldinger, DE, third team
2006—Mike DePersis, T, second team
2006—Nino Giambrone, G, second team
2006—Andy Perdie, DE, second team
2006—Dominick Ancona, P, second team
2007—James Wright, WR, second team
2007—Justin Hager, LB, second team
2007—James Alexander, CB, second team
2008—Ryan Aruck, DT, first team
2008—Justin Hager, LB, first team
2008—Drake Woodard, CB, first team
2008—Lance Boyington, CB, third team
2009—Andrew Marlier, RS, third team
2010—Devin Worthington, LB, first team
2011—Drake Woodard, CB, first team
2011—Brendan Hatlee, T, second team
2011—Tyre Coleman, DE, second team
2011—Devin Worthington, LB, second team
2012—Tyre Coleman, DE, first team
2012—Art Garvey, OG, first team
2012—Devin Worthington, LB, first team
2012—Bobby Dougherty, RB, second team
2012—Ali Marpet, OT, second team
2012—Nick Auriemma, DT, third team
2012—Steven Webb, RB, third team
2013—Tyre Coleman, DE, first team
2013—Michael Green, C, first team
2013—Fajri Jackson, CB, third team
2013—Ali Marpet, OT, second team
2013—Gabriel Smith, ST, first team
2013—Steven Webb, RB, first team
2013—Devin Worthington, LB, first team
2014 — Tyre Coleman, DL, first team
2014 — Fajri Jackson, DB, second team
2014 — Marcus Jemison, LB, third team
2014 — Ali Marpet, OL, first team
2014 — DeAndré Smith, OL, first team
2014 — Jacob Stanley, ST, third team
2015 — Marcus Jemison, LB, third team
2016 — Rio Schmidt, P, first team
2016 — Brandon Shed, WR, first team
2016 — Shane Sweeney, QB, second team
2016 — Nick Testani, C, second team
2016 — James Hedger, DE, third team
2017 — Kyle Hackett, K, third team
2017 — Rio Schmidt, P, second team
2017 — Shane Sweeney, QB, second team
2018 — Kyle Hackett, K, second team 
2018 — Matthew Woods, TE, third team
2019 — Rayshawn Boswell, RS, third team
2019 — Dillon Carey, OG, second team
2019 — Emmett Forde, LB, first team
2019 — Jared Leake, CB, second team
2021 — Tim Denham Jr., RB, first team
2021 — Emmett Forde, LB, first team
2021 — Jared Leake, DB, third team
2021 — Kieran Paskewitz, OL, third team
2022 — Anthony Romano, LB, second team
2024 — Jaimen Bliss, LB, first team
2024 — Ethan Kowalski, OL, second team
2024 — Vicente Lyon, P, first team
2024 — E.J. Taylor, RB, first team
2024 — Tobias Wefering, K, second team

 

---