An offensive guard, Smith was a D3football.com third team All-American in 2014. Smith was a key member of a dominant offensive line that ranked sixth in the nation in fewest sacks allowed (0.69/g) and fewest tackles for loss allowed (3.54/g). They helped Hobart rush for 200 yards or more six times, including a season-high 404 yards and six touchdowns against Merchant Marine. Smith did not allow a sack as the Statesmen advanced to the 2014 NCAA quarterfinals.