In 2017, Manning became Heron soccer's 25th NSCAA first team All-American. She also earned D3soccer.com second team All-American recognition that year.
A two-time All-East selection and a three-time all-conference pick. The 2017 Liberty League Player of the Year ranked first in the league with 13 goals, including five game winners, and 33 points. She led the Herons and was second in the conference with seven assists.
Â
In 83 career games, Manning produced 32 goals and 19 assists for 83 points. She finished her career tied for 12th on the William Smith career list for points, tied for 13th in assists and tied for 14th in goals.