A cornerback, Smith was named to the 2013 D3football.com All-America second team as a special teams player. He produced 14 tackles, three blocked punts, two pass breakups, one tackle for loss, and one forced fumble. He blocked two punts against Union, returning one 18 yards for a touchdown. Against St. Lawrence, Smith tackled the Saints' punter for an 11-yard loss and forced a fumble. The Statesmen recovered and scored a touchdown five plays later. Hobart went on to win 37-7, clinching its third straight Liberty League Championship.