A defender, Montgomery was named an All-American in each of her four seasons at William Smith. She earned first team honors from the IWLCA and USA Lacrosse Magazine in 2021 and Inside Lacrosse in 2020. The IWLCA recognized Montgomery as a second team All-American in 2019 and a third team selection in 2018.
Montgomery is just the second four-time All-American in William Smith lacrosse history, joining Amy Hoover '95.
Montgomery holds the William Smith career records for draw controls and caused turnovers as well as the single season and single game marks for draw controls.