Hobart and William Smith Colleges Athletics

Hinrichs was named to the 2021 United Soccer Coaches All-America Third Team. A first team All-Liberty League selection, she had 21 points. finishing the campaign with seven goals and seven assists. Three of her goals were game-winning tallies, including the decisive goal in the second overtime of the Liberty League championship game against Ithaca. Hinrichs added an assist in the semifinals on her way to being named the tournament's most outstanding performer.