As a senior, Schapiro posted a 20-1 singles record, capturing the Rolex Intercollegiate Tennis Northeast Region Championship to secure Hobart's first tennis All-America award. He completed his collegiate career with a four-year career singles record of 75-4 (.949) and a 61-11 (.847) mark in doubles action. Schapiro was inducted into the Hobart Athletics Hall of Fame with the Class of 2001.